Backplate or Jacket

[jasondbaker]

I have to agree with the good folks at Northland.  It would be really impractical to train students in a backplate+wing. I hate having to adjust my harness and I can't imagine having to adjust harnesses every day for for students.  Also, many of these students don't buy full sets of gear.  It makes sense for them to get familiar with gear they will probably rent in the tropics. 

I also agree with Qix.  Dive shops that sell backplates should take the opportunity to introduce them to students -- possibly as part of their advanced training.  I don't look at my initial purchase of a Balance bcd as a bad investment.  It was a great stepping stone to a backplate+wing.  I doubt I would have purchased a backplate+wing if given the option at the time.  The Balance seemed to be more user friendly and meet my newbie needs better. 

I have yet to participate in a sport or hobby where you buy the right/best/most advanced gear from the very beginning.  I guess that's so the more experienced guys can say "been there, done that".