Backplate or Jacket

[jasondbaker]

I originally started with a typical BC (seaquest balance) and graduated to a backplate+wing.  I have no problem recommending a back inflated BC like the Balance to someone.  That's probably as close to a backplate+wing as you can get.  I ultimately switched to a backplate because I wanted a more stable rig.  You just can't customize a BC and get the same level of solid stability.  The backplate is also very compact for traveling.

Now here are some of the few disadvantages of the backplate setup:

-- You probably need both a steel and an alum backplate if you dive in MN and the Caribbean so plan to spend a little more. One type doesn't generally fit all environments.
-- Backplate harnesses are a pain to configure. Once you dial the harness settings in you don't want to have to change it.  But this means that you can't share the backplate easily with another diver. Not a problem for me but it could be a problem for some.
-- No pockets.  This is a pain when diving in warm destinations and I need to store little camera items.  I have pockets on my drysuit so this isn't an issue when diving regionally.